Off-grid vs grid-connected: which is right for you?
Two ways to run a home on solar and a battery in Perth. Here is how they differ, what each one costs to run, and what tips the choice.
Quick answer for most Perth homeowners
For a Perth home that already has a grid connection, keeping it and adding a battery is the simpler path. An off-grid home needs a far bigger system and a generator, and it has to ration power on dull days. Off-grid makes sense where the grid is out of reach.
What is the difference between off-grid and grid-connected?
Whether the house keeps its connection to the grid. A grid-connected home with a battery still buys power from Synergy when the panels and battery run short. An off-grid home has no connection at all, so its panels, battery and a generator have to cover every day of the year on their own.
Grid-connected with battery (hybrid system)
Your home stays connected to the Synergy grid, with solar panels and a battery for storage. You run on solar and battery power when it is available, and on the grid when it is not. Excess solar exports to the grid for credits.
Off-grid system
Your home has no grid connection at all. Power comes entirely from your solar panels and battery storage, with a backup generator for extended cloudy periods or high-demand days.
Side-by-side comparison
| Factor | Grid-connected with a battery | Off-grid |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront cost | Lower (see the 10-year comparison below) | Much higher (bigger solar array and battery bank, plus a generator) |
| Rebates | Can qualify (WA Battery Scheme and federal STCs) | Outside the WA Battery Scheme, which needs a Synergy customer |
| Reliability | Very high (grid backup) | Moderate (generator backup) |
| Maintenance | Low | High (generator servicing) |
| Energy monitoring | Optional | Essential |
| Lifestyle impact | None | Significant |
Grid-connected with battery: detailed analysis
How it works
- Daytime: The panels power your home and charge the battery
- Evening: The battery runs the house through the dearer evening hours
- Overnight: The battery keeps going until it is empty, then the grid takes over
- Cloudy days: The grid fills the gap on its own
Advantages
Costs much less up front than an off-grid system (see the 10-year comparison below)
Can qualify for the WA Battery Scheme rebate (up to $1,300, counted on up to 10kWh) when the battery, inverter and household meet its rules, plus federal STCs (about $2,700–$3,500 for 10-13kWh)
The grid covers the shortfall after a run of cloudy days
Synergy Battery Rewards, a virtual power plant (VPP) that calls on home batteries at busy times, credits 70¢/kWh across 6–12 typical events a year
Run appliances as you do now; the grid tops up whatever the battery cannot cover
The WA Battery Scheme offers a no-interest loan to eligible households who join a VPP
Disadvantages
- Still pay Synergy's daily supply charge (about $1.19 a day)
- Without blackout protection, the house goes dark when the grid does
- Not truly "energy independent"
Suits:
- Perth metro area homes with grid access
- Households wanting to reduce bills without lifestyle changes
- Anyone planning to claim the rebates and join Synergy Battery Rewards
- Homes that use a lot of power (pools, air conditioning, EVs)
- Anyone watching the upfront cost
Off-grid system: detailed analysis
How it works
- Solar generation: A large solar array (say 10-15 kW) makes the power
- Battery storage: A big battery bank (30-50 kWh) stores what the house does not use
- Generator backup: A diesel or petrol generator covers long runs of cloud
- Energy management: A controller watches the battery and limits use when it runs low
System requirements
What an off-grid Perth home needs
- Solar array: 10-15 kW, far bigger than a grid-connected home needs
- Battery storage: 30-50 kWh, sized for dull days
- A backup generator
- An inverter-charger that can run the house with no grid
- A monitoring and control system
Advantages
No grid connection and no electricity bill
Save Synergy's daily supply charge, about $435 a year
Can cost less than running a new grid connection to a property
Every unit of power the house uses comes from its own system
Disadvantages
Needs a much larger solar array and battery bank, plus a generator
The WA Battery Scheme needs a Synergy customer who joins a VPP, so an off-grid home sits outside it
Regular servicing and fuel, plus the noise and fumes
Power has to be saved on dull days, most of all in winter
Someone has to keep an eye on the battery and the weather
Big appliances may need to run one at a time, or not at all
Suits:
- Properties where connecting to the grid would cost more than the system
- Holiday homes that use little power
- Households set on full energy independence
- People happy to manage their power use by hand
Decision framework
Choose grid-connected with battery if:
- ✓ Your Perth home already has a grid connection
- ✓ You want to reduce bills without lifestyle changes
- ✓ You want the WA battery rebate and federal STCs
- ✓ You want to join Synergy Battery Rewards
- ✓ You use a lot of power (pool, air conditioning, EV)
- ✓ You want reliable power without generator maintenance
- ✓ You want the lowest upfront cost
Choose off-grid if:
- ✓ Connecting to the grid would cost more than the system
- ✓ You're committed to complete energy independence
- ✓ You're willing to actively manage energy consumption
- ✓ You can fund a much larger system plus a generator
- ✓ You're comfortable with generator backup
- ✓ You have low to moderate energy needs
Cost comparison over 10 years
Grid-connected with a 10 kWh battery
- Upfront cost (after the WA Battery Scheme rebate and federal STCs): $2,987–$4,987
- Grid supply charge: $4,352 over 10 years at today's daily rate
- Grid top-up: whatever your solar and battery don't cover
- Synergy Battery Rewards credits on top, for each event the battery joins
Off-grid system
- Much larger battery bank and solar array, sized to carry you through cloudy days
- A backup generator, plus its fuel and servicing
- Earlier battery replacement, because the bank cycles deeply every day
Going off-grid swaps the supply charge for a far bigger system, a generator and its fuel. For a Perth home already on the grid, ask an installer to price both before you decide.
The hybrid approach
Some Perth homes stay on the grid and add blackout protection. That gives you:
- Normal grid-connected operation with battery storage
- A switch to battery power on its own when the grid goes down
- Backup power for the circuits you choose (fridge, lights, internet)
- Everything the grid connection brings: the rebates, Synergy Battery Rewards and grid backup
It adds to the system cost, so ask installers to price blackout protection on its own line. You avoid the limits of living fully off the grid.
Common misconceptions
"Off-grid is cheaper in the long run"
Reality: For a Perth home already on the grid, staying connected usually costs less, both up front and over the years. Off-grid pays its way where there is no grid connection, or where getting one would cost more than the system.
"I need to go off-grid to be energy independent"
Reality: A grid-connected battery lets you run on your own solar and stored power most of the time, with the grid behind you. Full independence costs a lot more, and you live with its limits.
"Off-grid systems are maintenance-free"
Reality: Off-grid systems need more upkeep. There is a generator to service, a bigger battery bank to look after and more energy to manage by hand.
Next steps
For a Perth metro home
A grid-connected battery costs less up front, can qualify for the rebates and keeps the grid behind you on a run of cloudy days. Off-grid is the answer when the grid is out of reach. Solar Battery Perth's battery matcher shows which grid-connected batteries fit your home.
Find the batteries that suit your home