The Tesla Powerwall 3 is a battery with a solar inverter built into the same box. BYD's Battery-Box is a tower of battery modules that runs with an inverter from another maker on BYD's list. Here is how the two compare on the facts, for a WA home.
Any spec table below takes each brand's models from the CEC register. The written comparison is our own summary. Specs, prices and eligibility change, so check the current details with your installer.
The Powerwall 3 is a complete system: a 13.5 kWh battery with a solar inverter inside the same box. The BYD Battery-Box Premium is the battery alone, a tower of modules that runs with an inverter from another maker on BYD's compatible list. With Tesla the system is decided for you; with BYD the inverter is chosen separately.
| Topic | Tesla | BYD |
|---|---|---|
| Product | Powerwall 3 | Battery-Box Premium HVS and HVM |
| What is in the box | Battery and solar inverter in one unit | Battery modules only, run by another maker's inverter from BYD's list |
| Usable capacity | 13.5 kWh a unit, and up to four units for 54 kWh | HVS 5.12 to 12.8 kWh, HVM 8.28 to 22.08 kWh a tower, and up to three towers |
| Sizing steps | One 13.5 kWh unit at a time | 2.56 kWh modules (HVS) or 2.76 kWh modules (HVM) |
| Continuous output | 5, 10 or 11.04 kW, set by the model code | Rises with each module: 5.12 to 12.8 kW (HVS), 7.68 to 20.48 kW (HVM) |
| Mounting | Wall or floor, 1,105 by 609 by 193 mm | Floor-standing tower; a full HVM stands 2,160 mm tall and weighs 319 kg |
| Operating range | -20°C to 50°C, with output possibly reduced above 40°C | -10°C to 50°C, and the warranty excludes damage outside it |
| Warranty | 10 years, 70% at the end, no cycle limit for self-consumption, time-based control and backup | 70% of usable energy for 10 years or until the minimum throughput energy, whichever first |
| WA Battery Scheme | Not eligible. Its built-in inverter is on Synergy's list but not approved for the scheme | Decided by the inverter it runs with, which must be on Synergy's list |
Neither drops in without a look at the inverter. The Powerwall 3 brings its own solar inverter, which can double up on the one already on the wall, so the installer checks compatibility first. A Battery-Box needs a high-voltage inverter from BYD's list. A home replacing its solar inverter can fit one of those and stand the tower beside it.
In WA, adding a battery to an existing solar system counts as an alteration and can trigger whole-of-site compliance, so compare an AC-coupled retrofit against replacing your inverter with a hybrid. For many existing systems the sound path is replacing toward a DC-coupled / hybrid-inverter setup rather than expanding an AC-coupled one, avoiding future compliance limitations.
The Powerwall 3 cannot. Its built-in inverter is on Synergy's list dated 1 October 2026 but is not approved for the WA Battery Scheme, and it cannot be swapped for one that is. A BYD battery depends on the inverter it runs with, chosen from BYD's compatible list, and that inverter has to be listed for battery storage on Synergy's list for the scheme.
Synergy's Supported Solutions List covers inverters approved for control. A battery system needs an inverter with a battery-storage (DER-Storage) listing on this list to be eligible for the WA Battery Scheme. A listing for generation only doesn't count. Other scheme conditions apply. Synergy's list goes by inverter model, so the quote should name the exact inverter model and firmware. The WA battery rebate guide sets out the scheme's other conditions.
Both run 10 years and promise 70% of capacity, but they count use differently. Tesla sets no cycle limit on the Powerwall 3 for self-consumption, time-based control and backup. BYD ends the 70% promise early if the tower delivers its energy limit first, which one full cycle a day reaches after about 8.2 to 8.5 years.
Uses outside self-consumption, time-based control and backup are capped at 37.8 MWh delivered. A Powerwall left offline for a long stretch, or never registered, may lose part of the 10 years, though at least four years from installation always stand. Claims go first to the Tesla certified installer who sold it.
The tower must go in within a month of its invoice, run with an inverter from BYD's list and never sit unused for six months or more. A module added later carries its own performance cover from its invoice date. Claims go in writing within 30 days to Alps Power, BYD's Australian service partner, and a later owner keeps the cover with proof of ownership.
The question is whether you want the system decided or assembled. The Powerwall 3 is one box with whole-home backup, but no WA rebate. A Battery-Box lets the inverter be chosen separately and the storage be sized in steps under 3 kWh, and its WA rebate position follows that inverter.
Get a quote from a member installer who covers your area. You choose whether to act on it. No obligation.
Not ready for a quote? Solar Battery Perth's battery matcher shows the systems that fit your usage, budget and backup needs, or you can compare all batteries.
Both systems sit in Solar Battery Perth's index of solar batteries for Perth, which lists every CEC-approved model in one comparable dataset.
Two modular systems Perth buyers often shortlist together, compared spec by spec.
Retrofit vs new install, efficiency trade-offs, and which brands use each type.
A 10 kWh usable LFP tower that stacks in 5 kWh modules, with a 10-year warranty.
The two all-in-one towers on Synergy's list, compared on backup, warranty terms and EV charging.
See annual savings and payback for your system, on current Synergy rates and WA rebates.
On sale here, but not on the approved-product register, so it earns no rebate.